When Bob Beall joined the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation’s medical staff in 1980,
he was intent on finding a cure for cystic fibrosis, which causes the lungs to
clog with mucus.
“The problem was that we didn’t know enough about the disease to be
able to think about how to intervene,” Beall says, “so we set out on a strategic
research agenda. First, we established research centers in leading institutions
around the country to help us get a better understanding of the disease, which
leads to chronic lung infections that often prove fatal.”
That effort culminated in 1989, when a team of CF Foundation-supported
scientists discovered the CF gene. “We had the gene, we had the science, and
we started to get a good understanding of what had gone wrong in CF patients,”
says Beall, who was named president and CEO of the CF Foundation in 1994.
What they didn’t have were pharmaceutical companies that were willing to
invest large sums of money to develop drugs that had the potential to counter
the effects of the defective CF gene.
That’s largely due to CF’s status as an “orphan disease,” so called because
it affects a relatively small number of people (about 30,000 in the U.S., 70,000
worldwide). That means that the profit potential from drugs that could eventually
be brought to market may not justify the amount of time, money and effort
it would take to develop those drugs.
“It’s estimated that it now takes an average of 14 years and $1.4 billion to
develop a new drug for any kind of disease,” Beall says, “so drug companies
don’t want to risk their money on orphan diseases when they can invest in the
development of treatments for diabetes, heart disease, and other illnesses that
affect a much larger number of people.”
It’s an economic reality that may seem harsh, but Beall has found a way to
soften the blow while directing the CF Foundation’s financial resources where
they can do the most good.
It’s called venture philanthropy, and it’s a concept that Beall has championed
as a way of getting biotechnology companies to overcome their reluctance
to pursue the development of drugs that will have a limited payoff—or
may never pay off at all.
“When you develop drugs you go through a discovery stage where you identify
compounds that may be effective against the disease, then you move to
the development stage where those compounds are put through clinical trials,”
Beall explains, noting that venture capitalists don’t like to invest in the early stages because it can take so long for them to get a return on their investment.
The idea behind venture philanthropy is to reduce the financial risk for
companies that are willing to conduct early drug discovery and development
research. “With venture philanthropy we pay for the early stages of a drug’s
development, and then the companies we’re investing in will take that drug
through clinical trials,” Beall says.
As part of the deal, the CF Foundation gets royalties or a share of the profits
from any drugs that eventually make it to market. The Foundation then reinvests
the money in new research or other early-stage development efforts to
start the cycle all over again. Since the inception of the program in 1998, the
Foundation has committed nearly $300 million to venture philanthropy.
Citing one such arrangement, Beall described the process that has led to
clinical trials for the two most promising drugs ever anticipated by cystic fibrosis
patients. They’re known as VX 770 and VX 809, and they’re offering hope
that the effects of cystic fibrosis can be mitigated more than ever before.
“To start the development process for these two products, we paid a
research company $42 million to screen hundreds of thousands of chemical
compounds to find a few that had the potential to correct the basic defect in
cystic fibrosis,” Beall explains.
“ It ’s estimated that it now takes an average of
14 years and $1.4 billion to develop a new drug
for any kind of disease so drug companies don’t
want to risk their money on orphan diseases...”
The two compounds are now being shepherded through clinical trials by
Vertex Pharmaceuticals—after what has grown to become a nearly $79 million
investment from the CF Foundation.
“It’s our biggest collaboration so far,” says Beall, who received an honorary
degree from Albright College in 1998 and has served as an Albright trustee since
2004. “Vertex will now spend more than $500 million to take the compounds
through clinical trials and hopefully get them to the point where they could
move to the patients.”
The prospects for the two compounds are particularly exciting because
they have the potential to treat the basic defect—not just the symptoms—of
the disease. “To treat the basic defect in a genetic disease like CF is very rare,
and to have it work is going to be exciting for our patients,” says Beall.
Most cystic fibrosis patients are diagnosed by the age of two. When the
Cystic Fibrosis Foundation was founded in 1955, the life expectancy was just
five years of age. Now it’s about 37. If the Vertex compounds work as anticipated,
CF patients could see another large gain in life expectancy.
“It’s not what you would call an ultimate cure, in that the disease goes away,but it provides for the ultimate treatment so that these drugs alone could add
decades of life for cystic fibrosis patients,” Beall says.
While the outlook for the Vertex compounds is promising, Beall is quick to
point out that they’re just two of the products the CF Foundation has in its drug
development pipeline. That pipeline now contains more than 30 drugs, all in
various stages of development, all aimed at improving and extending the lives of
cystic fibrosis patients, all made possible because of venture philanthropy.
It’s a concept that’s efficient, effective and potentially profitable, and it’s
getting attention because it works. For example, the CFF/Vertex venture
philanthropy partnership was recently used as a case study for the Harvard
Business School.
What’s more, Beall says, “Many patient-oriented, voluntary health
organizations are adopting this model because they’ve seen our success.
It’s changed the paradigm of how voluntary health organizations organize
themselves, but we stand out because of the size of our investments.”
In 2007, Beall notes, voluntary health organizations spent about $75
million, in total, on venture philanthropy. About $48 million of that was
invested by the CF Foundation.
“Even though we’re a ‘small’ disease we invest more money in investment
and research, per patient, than any other voluntary health organization,”
Beall says. “We have a $102 million research program,
which means that we have about $4,000 to invest in
research for every diagnosed patient. For such a
small community to raise so much money really
speaks to the passion of the families that we deal
with and the fact that they see the potential of
our drug development pipeline.”
But for Beall, bragging rights as the
largest venture philanthropist are meaningless. “The most important thing
is that venture philanthropy has
given us a development pipeline
for drugs that will make a
difference,” he says. “The
net result is that there’s
never been such a
sense of hope and
optimism in cystic
fibrosis as there
is today.” |