| Year | Inductees |
| 1989 | George Bollman '21
Charles Haines '32
Ed Cammarota '38 | Al Dittman '33
Dick Riffle '38
Gene Shirk |
| 1990 | Ed Anlian '50
George Conrad '56
Leo Disend '38 | Al Harnley '50
John Kopp '29
Eva Mosser |
| 1991 | Gary Chapman '61
Bill Dearden '44
Fran Hatton '33 | Stan Hino '34
Tom Pearsall '63
John Yocum '49 |
| 1992 | Grant Krow '63
Denny Zimmerman '70
Mike DePaul '56 | Wil Renken
John Potsklan |
| 1993 | Peggy Paul '78
Mike Klahr '66
Bernie Lillis '57 | Carmon Comunale '67
Haps Benfer '14 |
| 1994 | John Scholl '69
Hops Guldin '49 | Bill Kudrick '67
Terry Reber '57 |
| 1995 | Abe Karlip '31
Bruce Birkholz '62 | Steve George '68
Paul Mellini '74 |
| 1996 | Michael Bonner '39
George Seighman '62 | Dale Yoder '57
Beckie Yoder-Lamborn '83 |
| 1997 | Bob Ford '81
Nancy Jo Greenawalt '78 | Jim Kuhn '72 |
| 1998 | Bill Carey '80
Ray Feick '58 | Lynda Trzaska Leffler '71 |
| 1999 | Ray Granger '79 | Robert Ruoff '51 |
| 2000 | Mike Reedy '81 | Alison Koch Wallace '89 |
| 2001 | William R Kopp '66 | Frank Sudock '59
Jeanne Flickinger Person '48 |
| 2002 | Paul Litwinetz '72 | Nicole Buist '91
Jonathan Thorpe '92 |
| 2003 | Gerald Potts '52
Roy Dragon '56 | Paul Chaiet '67
Jarra Rusnock '98 |
| 2004 | Bill Bors '65
Frank Francks '77 | Jenis Frederick
|
| 2005 | Norm Jowitt '38
Mike Eckenroth '68 | Barb Stubenrauch-Lightner '84
|
| 2006 | Bill Morrison '74
Bob Maro '99 | Carrie Miller '01
|
| 2007 | Ryan Ditze '96
Wendy Frese-Irwin '77 | Dave Kurzinsky '77
|
| 2008 | William Henry "Lone Star" Dietz
Terry Rhodes '70 | Shawn Swavely '00 |
